Jon Corzine's near tragic accident has interrupted an intense debate among journalists, legislators and federal prosecutors. The subject has been the legislative practice of placing "Christmas Tree" items in appropriations legislation.
The speculation has been that these expenditures, quietly placed in legislation during the still of the night, are inevitably self serving and wasteful. The Governor's accident, rather than distracting from this debate, might actually shed a little light on the subject.
Governor Corzine might owe his life to the quick evacuation to the trauma center at Cooper Hospital. Cooper has long possessed a quality emergency unit that was the rival of its North Jersey counterparts. What it didn't posses was a modern helicopter landing facility that could get patients efficiently from the site of an accident to an operating table.
It was a vulnerability that wasn't fair to the people of South Jersey. Neither the bureaucracy in Trenton or Washington responded. What did work was the political system.
One night I approached Senator Byrd, chairman of the Senate Appropriations Committee, with a request. The President's Budget had ignored requests to strengthen emergency evacuation in southern New Jersey by replacing the inadequate helicopter landing pad at Cooper Hospital. The item was too small to gather legislative support. I needed him to insert a line item in an appropriation bill.
The result was the construction of a new emergency landing site at Cooper Hospital. A more immediate result was the rapid response to the Governor's accident. The larger point is that neither legislative leaders nor the appointed bureaucracy are always the best allocators of resources. What sometimes works best is individual legislators responding to requests from constituents.
What makes this such a great example is that only one person ever called to ask for the new helicopter pad. It was George Norcross.
Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (CREW), a watchdog group that promotes ethics and accountability, has filed a complaint with the ... >
There's nothing more difficult to see than the history before your eyes. It sometimes takes generations to understand the significance of ... >
OK, he didn't say precisely that, but when the Chairman of the Budget Committee informs us that governmental spending is the key to prosperity, ... >
Score one for the Governor’s public relations team. For the last few weeks, they have been working overtime to fuel speculation Corzine was being ... >
I am pleased to report the results from the first national poll conducted by Environmental Studies Program in the College of Arts and Sciences at ... >
To view a larger version of this cartoon, click here. >
The media, which loves headlines and knows little history, is trying to sell President Elect Obama as another Franklin Delano Roosevelt. But that ... >
When I was eleven, way back in 1965, my family was invited for Thanksgiving to my cousins’ cousins, a Jewish-Italian family who lived in the ... >
After the entire Star-Ledger editorial board opted to accept the paper's buyout offer, John Farmer, a 26-year veteran of the paper, was tasked ... >
A couple of weeks ago, my mother, Angelina Katz, did her second debate on behalf of Barack Obama. A debate? My mother? If you knew her, you’d be ... >
A rained out MusicFest this past September has provided Union County with $275,000 in insurance monies. The Union County Board of Chosen Freeholders ... >
Today the Asinine Watch begins. With so many illiterate statements made about the economy by elected officials in recent days and weeks, it was ... >
Saint George Norcross
Torricelli forget to laud Mussolini for making the trains run on time.
Well, at least you stayed away from National Socialism
So comparing Norcross to Mussolini now? Sheesh.
listening to constituents
No one can doubt that the new helicopter launchpad was a worthwile expenditure...but George Norcross is no average constituent asking for a little gov't help.
Would Torch have been as receptive to the little man who didn't control South Jersey?
vomit in my mouth
Just think of all the nameless victims airlifted to Cooper who owe Torricelli their lives. (not to mention Senator Byrd.) What a Self-aggrandizing twit!
Self-Congratulations
Gentlemen do not pat themselves on the back, sir. Rather, they await others to point out their accomplishments. That no one was pointing out yours is telling. There is a right way and a wrong way to procure funding for a project. Earmarks sir, is not the correct way.
That is quite telling in itself. I have no doubt you think it is true, but consider 100 senators all running around responding to requests of political bosses back home. Is it any wonder that faith in the political system is so low? http://blog.ladow.net
Again, drivel ... and yet, fascinating
"The result was the construction of a new emergency landing site at Cooper Hospital. A more immediate result was the rapid response to the Governor's accident."Â
There's just one small problem with these two sentences in conjunction: The Governor wasn't flown to the hospital in a helicopter because of the high winds lashing New Jersey on Friday -- the same reason he was driving on the Garden State Parkway in the first place, rather than flying back to Drumthwacket.Â
So, forgive me, Mr. Torricelli, but how exactly did the construction of a new emergency landing site at Cooper Hospital result in a rapid response to the Governor's accident?Â
Beyond the obvious inanity of Mr. Torricelli's linkage above, though, this post is fascinating. According to Mr. Torricelli's account, George Norcross called (in fact, he was the "only one" to call) and asked for a federal appropriation to construct a helicopter landing pad at Cooper Hospital. Mr. Torricelli, by his own admission, could not "gather legislative support" -- i.e., he couldn't win approval for the appropriation in committee (where it would be examined, evaluated, and compared and contrasted to other potential uses of limited funds -- the very definition of a political exercise). So, instead, he went to see the chairman of the Senate appropriations committee, and asked that the line item be inserted without any legislative oversight. And Sen. Byrd accommodated him.Â
Question: who got the contract to construct the new helipad at Cooper Hospital? Could it have been ... oh, say, JCA Associates, George Norcross' favorite Moorestown engineering firm?Â
Perhaps some enterprising reporter would like to follow up on this.Â
And it leaves one wondering ... perhaps I'm being a bit too Machiavellian, even for New Jersey (if that's possible), but could the real reason for this post, covered in typical Torricelli "look at me!" style, have been to point federal and state investigators to this one transaction? Is Mr. Torricelli secretly hoping to throw Mr. Norcross under the bus?
correction?
Bill, not that I relish coming to the Torch's defense, but the Ledger's story on Sunday "A night of high stakes drama" has this sentence from Josh Margolin: "About 6:25 p.m. the helicopter carrying the governor lifted off the Garden State Parkway, where traffic had been blocked off for four miles." Jack
sort of agree w/ Pascoe (wow...)
If I find myself agreeing w/ Pascoe again I think my head might explode.
But for now....the problem w/ earmarks isn't the "good" projects like a helicopter pad at a hospital...its the "bridge to nowhere" type line-items that get inserted the same way. But to stop the wasteful projects, the worthwile ones need to go through the open process too.
As for King George, his motives for helping Camden and Cooper Hospital I believe are largely pure, even if his methods tend to be Boss-style politics.
 I also find it troubling if Norcross was truly the only one calling....where were the City officials and State Representatives pushing for hometown projects? Why is GN the only one who seems to care?
Byrd to Norcross to Mussolini Comparing?
They’re about the same size.
Come to think about it the last time I saw Mr. Plastic his arms were folded.
Earmarks Are A Perverse Corruption of...
...the legislative process. Ideally (I confess, I'm an idealist) every proposed expenditure should be in the actual bills long before they are voted on.
 There should be time for judgment and analysis to be applied AND the process should be transparent in real time...that means posted to the WWW so that anyone and everyone can scrutinize the details and feed back into the process.
Further, when the appropriation gets to the stage of being implemented every bid and every detail of the bid that can be legally released needs to be posted so that all and any interested parties can scrutinize it before a contract is procured/signed.
In other words, governance should be totally open, transparent and responsive to the broader community of it's constituents in real time on just about everything...not just in vague general terms on election day.
Obviously, there are military items that may not be so open; but there needs to be far more oversight than there is now....instead of punishing incompetence (that's a charitable adjective) when contracts "run over" the alloted funds, the miscreants are rewarded with more money to not finish the job.
I wonder how much less we would be spending if the money was spent the same way most people carefully spend their own money?
Too many contractors/vendors have been getting filthy rich sucking at the teat of government.
In many, if not all, cases these same entities that profit so much are big "contributors" to the campaigns of the folks appropriating the funds!
That's legalized bribery!
I apologize ...
For my failure to more thoroughly research the particulars of the Governor's mode of travel to Cooper Hospital. In our business, sloppy research is a cardinal sin (and, not surprisingly, a MASSIVE personal pet peeve), and I screwed up royally. I relied on my memory of one of the initial news alerts that evening, which (incorrectly, as it turned out) reported that the high winds in the area had prevented travel by helicopter.Â
Mr. Torricelli, I apologize.
THE MORALE OF THE STORY IS....
The morale of the story is, he who throws business to David Chang's concrete and helipad building company, often have fortuitious good luck in telling tall tales later.
TORCH LOGIC???
C'mon, is Toricelli really writing this with a straight face? Telling us the only way to get a needed hospital helicopter pad funded is through a secretive, undemocratic earmark (or Chistmas tree) process is as absurd as it is sad. And Norcross, who chairs the Cooper hospital board and has the power to direct funding and contracts to his crony friends and firms to construct said helicopter pad, is supposedly only looking out for the good of all of us in South Jersey?? Pa-Leeze! Using the governor's trajedy to justify pork-barrel spending, secret earmarks and political bosses - not to mention patting himself on the back - is disgusting. Thank God we are rid of this self-serving, arrogant politician.
The Torch
WHEN WHEN is this man ever going to leave our lives. I wish he would run again just to get rid of him!
He Just Doesn't Get It...
It's a shame that, after all he's been through, Bob Torricelli STILL is unable/unwilling to See that his whole "modus operandi" was/is WRONG!
The rationale/defense of earmarks put forth above is, literally, ridiculous.....and, has been appropriately ridiculed.
Unfortunately, there are too many pols that think of constituents the same way that con artists think of their "marks".
Pay to play, sweetheart deals, cronyism, nepotism and the whole concept of bossism are anachronistic relics of the 19th century that were dated 100 years ago and are now choking the body politic to death.
There are LIMITS to how much can be ripped off. There isn't any more "fat" left to skim.
The local, county, state, national and world situations require objective, competent, honest, and systemic solutions.
The same old **** (enter the four letter word that fits) simply doesn't cut it.
People are dying as a result of the, essentially corrupt, status quo.
Bob, it's time to let go of trying to justify your old political career...if you want to make a contribution/difference; please consider doing a 180 (like John Dean has) and turning on the old paradigms. Thank you.
From Frederick Douglass
Why? why?
Why does this guy keep blogging here when he is so universally despised? Does he get up from the keyboard, put on his assless leather chaps, and submit himself to Mistress Broomhilda? Without a safe word?
detractors of bob
bob you finished a winner---great farm ---great house dog and horse --glad to have you as a neighbor---also thanks for your good works in lambertville---they need help
im sure he has done more for
im sure he has done more for his communit than any of you belly achers
Get well, Gov Corzine
The state really needs you, like it has few governors in recent memory. Continue the good work I've seen thus far, and make a strong case for a line item veto, which I think will scotch these Christmas Tree goodies in the bud!
He'd win
Karlcat, NJ has some of the worst voters in America (and perhaps in American history). I think we surpassed Louisiana in corrupt officials. While he would have lost to Forrester, I think that has all blown over now, and the voters forget. If Bob the Torch ran again, I think he would win, I think NJ voters would vote for anyone with a D next to their name no matter how corrupt they may be.